What's weird is that I was on last night and didn't see this or your other cigar thread.
So here's my take on cigars. I can tell the difference between a 50cent and a $5 cigar. I can't tell much difference between a $5 cigar and a $20 cigar, so keep that in mind. I'm the same way with wines. Up to a certain point I can't tell or don't appreciate paying more.
Cigar shops are great MANLY establishments. They usually have a great selection but being the cheap son of a gun that I am, I order online. And right now my go-to is Cigars International. They're up in Ohio.
I buy their "knock-offs". I enjoy the Macanudo Churchill when I want a milder smoke and the Cohiba when I'm in a spicier mood.
I'll tell ya, another good pairing with a cigar is a good gin martini. The flavors mix well. One cigar is usually good for two martinis. Maybe three. But after three it's easy to fall down so that's not good.
I'm diggin' on the New Amsterdam gin these days. Nice flavor and won't break the bank.
http://www.cigarsinternational.com/search/?q=CI+Knock+Offs