To inform or not to inform

Howard Law
fyroc

fyroc

Developer
Mar 25, 2015
482
270
113
Philadelphia
Zip code
19130
I recently go into a debate about whether you should inform an LEO that you have a firearm or not. This debate started due to this article.

http://speedsociety.com/how-to-info...-are-carrying-a-handgun-and-live/?source=dave

I use to be a firearms instructor when I was in Savannah. Nothing too big.. I worked part time at a range while I was trying to advance my dev career. One of our biggest questions was how to handle a traffic stop. My advice was this...

It's case by case. 90% of the time, if you are in a state where you do not have to inform, don't. By informing an officer you have a firearm in your vehicle you are creating a more stressful environment for both you and the police officer. The best thing to do, is to give him the information needed only for that traffic stop, take your ticket, and leave. If they ask if you have any weapons, I would respond, "I do not have any illegal weapons".

The other 10% of the time, you may want to inform. That 10% is when you are being asked out of the vehicle and the gun is on your person. Or when the vehicle is being searched.

What are your guys feelings?
 
Laufen

Laufen

Beloved flaming retard
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 23, 2015
7,927
6,129
113
I85
Zip code
30030
fyroc said:
I recently go into a debate about whether you should inform an LEO that you have a firearm or not. This debate started due to this article.

http://speedsociety.com/how-to-info...-are-carrying-a-handgun-and-live/?source=dave

I use to be a firearms instructor when I was in Savannah. Nothing too big.. I worked part time at a range while I was trying to advance my dev career. One of our biggest questions was how to handle a traffic stop. My advice was this...

It's case by case. 90% of the time, if you are in a state where you do not have to inform, don't. By informing an officer you have a firearm in your vehicle you are creating a more stressful environment for both you and the police officer. The best thing to do, is to give him the information needed only for that traffic stop, take your ticket, and leave. If they ask if you have any weapons, I would respond, "I do not have any illegal weapons".

The other 10% of the time, you may want to inform. That 10% is when you are being asked out of the vehicle and the gun is on your person. Or when the vehicle is being searched.

What are your guys feelings?
Click to expand...
In GA you don't have the obligation to inform. It's one of the only states in the union like that though. I would never bring it up unless asked explicitly.


Oh, and.........."am I being detained?"
 
  • Like
Reactions: Red Dawn
AtlMedic

AtlMedic

Not A Doctor
Mar 25, 2015
2,644
1,441
113
Smyrna, GA
Zip code
30082
fyroc said:
I recently go into a debate about whether you should inform an LEO that you have a firearm or not. This debate started due to this article.

http://speedsociety.com/how-to-info...-are-carrying-a-handgun-and-live/?source=dave

I use to be a firearms instructor when I was in Savannah. Nothing too big.. I worked part time at a range while I was trying to advance my dev career. One of our biggest questions was how to handle a traffic stop. My advice was this...

It's case by case. 90% of the time, if you are in a state where you do not have to inform, don't. By informing an officer you have a firearm in your vehicle you are creating a more stressful environment for both you and the police officer. The best thing to do, is to give him the information needed only for that traffic stop, take your ticket, and leave. If they ask if you have any weapons, I would respond, "I do not have any illegal weapons".

The other 10% of the time, you may want to inform. That 10% is when you are being asked out of the vehicle and the gun is on your person. Or when the vehicle is being searched.

What are your guys feelings?
Click to expand...
I agree with your statement. No need to bring it up if not asked.
 
AirOpsMgr

AirOpsMgr

Director of Lavatory Services
Administrator
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 24, 2015
3,775
10,730
4,294,967,295
30354
fyroc said:
I recently go into a debate about whether you should inform an LEO that you have a firearm or not. This debate started due to this article.

http://speedsociety.com/how-to-info...-are-carrying-a-handgun-and-live/?source=dave

I use to be a firearms instructor when I was in Savannah. Nothing too big.. I worked part time at a range while I was trying to advance my dev career. One of our biggest questions was how to handle a traffic stop. My advice was this...

It's case by case. 90% of the time, if you are in a state where you do not have to inform, don't. By informing an officer you have a firearm in your vehicle you are creating a more stressful environment for both you and the police officer. The best thing to do, is to give him the information needed only for that traffic stop, take your ticket, and leave. If they ask if you have any weapons, I would respond, "I do not have any illegal weapons".

The other 10% of the time, you may want to inform. That 10% is when you are being asked out of the vehicle and the gun is on your person. Or when the vehicle is being searched.

What are your guys feelings?
Click to expand...
Even though GA does not require notification, I still do it (a lot of my family, back in another state that requires it, are LEO and we've discussed this many times).

In the 3 encounters I've had here in GA, I've put my hands on the door sill, LEO approaches and I advise that I have a firearm at my 3 O'clock and have my GA permit; they then ask me what department I work for, I advise I'm not LEO and they then say okay, just need your license real quick.

That said, I have had the "what if" conversation with my LEO family as to what to do if you run across a newbie, fresh-out of POST, their response; yeah, good luck.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: dial1911
karlvv

karlvv

The LEGEND
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Apr 3, 2015
3,784
12,415
113
Harlem, GA
Zip code
30814
I would take it case by case, but if it becomes such an issue, you might want to take a driving class.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AirOpsMgr
AirOpsMgr

AirOpsMgr

Director of Lavatory Services
Administrator
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 24, 2015
3,775
10,730
4,294,967,295
30354
karlvv said:
I would take it case by case, but if it becomes such an issue, you might want to take a driving class.
Click to expand...
Unless you live in a area like I do where they throw up road-side safety checks every July 4th, Labor Day and Memorial Day...
 
Jake

Jake

Steering wheel holder
Super Moderator
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Aug 11, 2015
8,361
36,820
113
Ball Ground
Zip code
30189
I'm not giving any more info than necessary.
 
Mac11FA

Mac11FA

Disgruntled large member
Super Moderator
Lifetime Supporter
Patriot Lifetime
Mar 26, 2015
3,840
3,011
113
Locust Grove, GA
Zip code
30248
Don't ask don't tell. If they do not specifically asked, then I don't say anything.
 
Huddy

Huddy

Tracker
Lifetime Supporter
Jan 5, 2016
564
1,499
113
Cumming, GA
Zip code
30040
Knock on wood, it's been a long time since I've been pulled over so I have no experience with the situation. However, a cousin in Ohio has told me both times he was pulled over he was first asked if he was carrying a weapon that day. Sounds like they pull carry license info when they run plates there. Anyone ever heard of that down here?
 
Red Dawn

Red Dawn

Wolverines
Site Supporter
Lifetime Supporter
Aug 12, 2015
5,743
6,957
113
H Town
Zip code
30228
I don't think it's a problem here for law abiding citizens. I've never offered up any info and have never been asked either. Now if your asked to exit the vehicle then you might want to offer up some info as to not cause panic when it's seen by the officer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huddy
Huddy

Huddy

Tracker
Lifetime Supporter
Jan 5, 2016
564
1,499
113
Cumming, GA
Zip code
30040
Red Dawn said:
I don't think it's a problem here for law abiding citizens. I've never offered up any info and have never been asked either. Now if your asked to exit the vehicle then you might want to offer up some info as to not cause panic when it's seen by the officer.
Click to expand...

I switched my wallet carry pocket so that it's not on my weapon side for this reason. I guess, if asked to exit the vehicle, I would inform the officer of the location of my firearm and my wallet so there would be no confusion as to which I was reaching for. Are officers allowed to remove your firearm from your possession during a stop? I've always wondered that as I would have serious apprehension about allowing them to take possession of my weapon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Red Dawn
Red Dawn

Red Dawn

Wolverines
Site Supporter
Lifetime Supporter
Aug 12, 2015
5,743
6,957
113
H Town
Zip code
30228
Huddy said:
I switched my wallet carry pocket so that it's not on my weapon side for this reason. I guess, if asked to exit the vehicle, I would inform the officer of the location of my firearm and my wallet so there would be no confusion as to which I was reaching for. Are officers allowed to remove your firearm from your possession during a stop? I've always wondered that as I would have serious apprehension about allowing them to take possession of my weapon.
Click to expand...
Once notified they can in fact run a check to see if it's stolen is all I think since we don't register in GA
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom