Poly or Alum?

Howard Law

permaneo vox

Powered by Silencer Shop
Trusted Trader
Sep 21, 2015
426
281
93
Heart of Georgia
Zip code
31020
For firing, it doesn't matter.

For rough service and dropping or what some may call abuse, forged aluminum.

I've seen cast aluminum lowers break at the buffer tube when falling over.
 

dial1911

Waiting for the flash
Site Supporter
Jul 15, 2015
7,331
27,066
113
Anywhere but here
southeastoutdoors.boards.net
I've read the forged vs. cast arguments too many times.

I have designed repairs for many airplanes and I will tell you that forged only gets a small increase in strength vs. a billet part. Casting has inherent problems that are hard to overcome without a post casting heat treat/stress relief process.

The most important thing for strength, as far as aluminum is concerned, its the composition of the material. 6061-T6 is the crap hole of aluminum material. 7075-T6 is freaking awesome- literally double the yield strength of the 6061 stuff. The "T-number" after the first four digits refers to the heat treat of the material. -O "plain" is the worst. -T43/-T6/-T63 all vary in their properties as far as the material is concerned.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cmshoot

cmshoot

Marksman
Jul 12, 2016
1,403
1,710
113
Dallas, GA
Zip code
30132
I've read the forged vs. cast arguments too many times.

I have designed repairs for many airplanes and I will tell you that forged only gets a small increase in strength vs. a billet part. Casting has inherent problems that are hard to overcome without a post casting heat treat/stress relief process.

The most important thing for strength, as far as aluminum is concerned, its the composition of the material. 6061-T6 is the crap hole of aluminum material. 7075-T6 is freaking awesome- literally double the yield strength of the 6061 stuff. The "T-number" after the first four digits refers to the heat treat of the material. -O "plain" is the worst. -T43/-T6/-T63 all vary in their properties as far as the material is concerned.

Great info!
 

boss_hawg

Marksman
Jul 13, 2015
1,230
1,045
113
Zip code
30328
General question poly or aluminum lower for the wimpy .556?

I've always wondered if it really matters.

A .556MM rifle would be very wimpy indeed...if it existed.

Or were you talking about a .556 inch caliber beast? Probably not a wimp at all!

For 5.56MM rifles, I prefer the strength of metal to prevent wear and slop at the pin holes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Strider12

PewPewPewCo

Sniper
Mar 23, 2015
2,139
1,075
113
Georgia
where on earth are you guys finding cast aluminum lowers and not forged or billet?

Honestly, the new plastic lowers are pretty damn durable, they just dont have the resale value because people want the metal because they've always used the metal.

If going polymer, pick up a TNarms lower. they even make AR10 lowers.
 

Laufen

Beloved flaming retard
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 23, 2015
7,927
6,129
113
I85
Zip code
30030
A .556MM rifle would be very wimpy indeed...if it existed.

Or were you talking about a .556 inch caliber beast? Probably not a wimp at all!

For 5.56MM rifles, I prefer the strength of metal to prevent wear and slop at the pin holes.
That's the reason I've never gone with poly.
 

cmshoot

Marksman
Jul 12, 2016
1,403
1,710
113
Dallas, GA
Zip code
30132
If you decide you wanna go poly, make sure you get one with steel inserts at the pin holes, and a metal-reinforced collar where the receiver extension (aka buffer tube) attaches.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Creeper

Wallace

Tracker
Trusted Trader
Mar 26, 2015
828
370
113
Cartersville
Zip code
30145
Absolutely no reason to buy a poly AR lower with the current price of forged ones so low.

I have had one and it sucked ass. Fit was way to tight. Very rough and just didnt seem very robust.

IMG_20130304_205226.jpg


tumblr_mtomx4ol3H1qdrno0o5_1280.jpg

tumblr_mtomx4ol3H1qdrno0o1_1280.jpg

pclfailure2.jpg



...and then there is this from a couple years ago:

http://www.ar15.com/forums/t_1_5/16...ass_Lowers___Anyone_else_buy_one___PICS_.html
 

freedom

Sniper
Mar 25, 2015
1,522
885
113
Covington, Ga
Zip code
30014
I had a poly at one point. I think I purchased a complete new frontier for $109 back around the same time a LRB forged lower was the cheapest option at $79. It even had a poly trigger and hammer. I mated it to a CMMG 22 upper but never shot it much. The trigger was actually smoother most milspec trigger groups.

I sold it after sandy hook for $350.